Skip to Content

Jello Ice Cream – Easy, Creamy and Delicious!

Share this Recipe!

Sweet, creamy fruity real ice cream with a box of jello thrown in. Jello Ice Cream can be made with or without an ice cream machine. Easy & Delicious!

Real Jello Ice Cream with or without a machine!

Most of my readers know that my daughter blessed me with the gift of my first grandbaby very recently. In fact, today he is 10 days old.

Introducing Carsyn Oliver, born February 22, 2016 at 10:48am. He was a whopping 8lbs 1 oz  and 21″ long, even though he was a week early, and while that’s not huge, for my daughter’s petite size, it sure was.

He is an absolute gift from God, a true blessing. I simply cannot get enough of him. They live with me, so trust me I am soaking up the love.

Carsyn Oliver
So, her due date was February 29, Happy Leap Year. haha He decided to come visit a little early, which was okay but was unexpected since we were told he would probably be on time or a week late.

The week before Carsyn was due to arrive, we began planning some blog posts for my blogs for when he was born and the immediate week after. My daughter is my partner in recipe developing as well as my part-time photographer.

We knew we had to get ahead.

Real Jello Ice Cream with or without a machine!
We had seen a recipe for Jello Sherbet Ice Cream floating around Pinterest that had seriously been teasing us.

We were trying to save it for summer just to have some fun with it, but decided it might be fun (because of the soft colors) to do for Spring. 

Honestly in honor of the upcoming arrival of her sweet little one (you know, sweet – pastel colors, kids love jello – Jello Ice Cream, just go with it).

Here is the original recipe: Jello Sherbet Ice Cream.

We changed it up a little and made it the way I make my real vanilla ice cream, just with the jello mix added.

I wanted to use as many pure ingredients since I was using the jello too, plus we didn’t have any ice cream mix, and couldn’t find it.

So I improvised and I’m really glad I did. This Jello Ice Cream was so easy and was incredibly creamy and delicious!

Real Jello Ice Cream with or without a machine!
I tried one batch of Jello Ice Cream in four flavors with the ice cream maker, and one batch of all four flavors without an ice cream maker.

Both batches worked perfect.

The only real difference is that the batch that used the ice cream maker was frozen faster but took longer to prepare all four flavors.

Mostly since I had to freeze the bucket in between each one.

However if you are using only one flavor, you could totally use an ice cream maker and it will be a little firmer than soft serve when done.

SO good!

Freeze in the freezer for an additional 2 hours for a more traditional ice cream.

Real Jello Ice Cream with or without a machine!

What did it taste like? Well, depending on the flavors you choose – we chose blue raspberry, watermelon, island pineapple and some odd Star Wars Rebel Force Berry which tasted a lot like watermelon and wasn’t lime which was what we didn’t want.

At any rate, all the flavors were very good.

The ice cream was fruity, creamy and tasted just like if we had purchased a store bought brand of ice cream.

Really the ingredients tasted stronger which is why I like homemade ice cream better anyway.

Smooth, silky and creamy.

Also if you want a cute way to serve this ice cream or any that I share, my friend Ellen  has these adorable Ice Cream Cones. Just change out the sprinkles and you’ve got anything you want! 

Ready to make some Jello Ice Cream?

Jello Ice Cream

Creamy Jello Ice Cream

Yield: 1 quart
Prep Time: 5 minutes
Freeze: 8 hours
Total Time: 8 hours 5 minutes

Sweet, creamy fruity real ice cream with a box of jello thrown in. Jello Ice Cream can be made with or without an ice cream machine. Easy & Delicious!

Ingredients

  • 2 cups heavy cream
  • 2 cups whole milk
  • ¾ cup sugar
  • 2 teaspoons vanilla
  • 1 pkg., 3 oz. JELL-O ANY Flavor Gelatin

Instructions

  1. In a mixer, mix together all of the ingredients on low until completely combined.
  2. Pour into your ice cream machine container according to the manufacturers instructions.
  3. Once it'd done, you can either eat it then or you can freeze it a little longer to make it a little firmer.
  4. If you are not using an ice cream machine, pour the mixture into a freezer safe container with an airtight lid.
  5. Freeze for about 8 hours (or overnight).

Did you make this recipe?

Please leave a comment on the blog or share a photo on Pinterest

Want more ice cream? Here are some fun ice cream recipe ideas!  

What is your favorite flavor of jello, and will you be trying this Ice Cream?

Share this Recipe!

Tell Us What You Think!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Leona

Wednesday 14th of August 2019

Could I replace the sugar with Swerve?

Nicole Cook

Wednesday 14th of August 2019

You can certainly try. I do not know if it will change the consistency of the ice cream or not, since I have never tried that. Let me know if it works if you decide to try it, I'm curious now.

Oie White

Saturday 27th of January 2018

i just make some hope it turn out good!

Nicole Cook

Friday 2nd of February 2018

I hope it turned out too!! We love it here and make it quite often with different flavors. ;)

Heather

Monday 26th of June 2017

I made this it's yummy! I used sugar free jello and steevia instead. I found I got a waxy texture on my spoon and mouth after eating. Did you whip the cream mixture before putting it in ice cream maker?

Nicole Cook

Wednesday 28th of June 2017

I did not whip the mixture at all. I am suspecting the waxy texture might be the sugar free oppose to the regular jello. Not sure though. I'm glad it was still good! <3

Nikki @ Nik Snacks

Saturday 12th of March 2016

I'm so glad you didn't use an ice cream mix. Blechhh! And congrats on your grandbaby! Yay! He most certainly is a beautiful boy!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Skip to Recipe